Over-rehearsing
Practicing far past what improves the performance.
The fear loops · Public speaking & stage fright
By Matt Codde, LCSW — Founder, Restored MindsLast reviewed
Shaky voice, blanking on stage, rehearsing for hours, unable to hit "publish"? Learn how public speaking anxiety, stage fright, and writer's block work — and how the Triple-A Response® breaks the loop.
You're next. You've rehearsed this fifteen times. And as you walk to the front of the room, your throat closes, your hands start shaking, and the first line you've said a hundred times is suddenly gone.
Or it's a different stage: the blank page, the song you've written and never played for anyone, the post that's been sitting in your drafts for three months.
Creative performance anxiety is a fear loop in which recurring dread about being judged for what you say, perform, or create drives over-rehearsal, self-monitoring, perfectionism, reassurance-seeking, replaying, and avoidance. Its most common forms are public speaking anxiety (including presentations and pitches), stage fright (music, theater, dance, comedy), and writer's block or the fear of sharing creative work.
What makes this loop especially painful is that it attacks the thing you care about most. The writer who loves to write can't. The musician who loves to play can't do it in front of people. The person with something real to say doesn't say it.
Here's the sentence that matters most, and the rest of this page will earn it: stage fright and writer's block aren't creative failures. They're fear loops that chose your creative life as their target.
Before: dread that starts days or weeks out. Rehearsing over and over, not to improve but to feel safe. Scripting every word. Thinking about canceling — or canceling.
During: watching yourself. Is my voice shaking? Do they look bored? That sentence came out wrong. Rushing to get it over with. Reading from the slides. Holding the notes tight so no one sees your hands.
After: replaying the stumble, the pause, the question you didn't answer well. Reading every face in your memory for disapproval.
On the page or in the studio: the inner critic before the first word. Drafting and deleting. Revising the same piece for months. Finishing the work and not being able to send it, post it, or play it for anyone.
And over time, the stage gets smaller. You turn down the talk, skip the open mic, stop submitting, stop writing.
Same shape underneath: if I show people what I have, they'll judge it — and me — as not good enough.
Practicing far past what improves the performance.
Memorizing every word so nothing can go wrong.
Watching your voice, face, hands, and the audience's reactions in real time.
Revising endlessly, unable to call it finished.
"Was that okay?" "Is this good?" — asked of friends, colleagues, anyone.
Going over the performance afterward, looking for what went wrong.
Smaller stages, fewer audiences, shorter talks, work that never gets shared.
Canceling, declining, never submitting, never starting.
Each one brings relief. Each one teaches your system that being seen is dangerous.
The chest: tight, braced, heart pounding — and the pounding itself can become something to fear. The throat and voice: tight, dry, shaky; the words stuck or gone. The hands: trembling on the notes, the mic, the instrument. The breath: shallow and high, which makes the voice thinner and shakier. The mind: going blank.
And here's the trap: the shaky voice you're afraid of gets worse the more you fight it. Watching for the tremble keeps your attention on it, tightens your throat, and shortens your breath — which produces more tremble.
Good creative performance comes from outward-facing presence — attention on the idea, the audience, the music, the story. Self-monitoring pulls attention inward, to watch and judge. You can't fully be in the moment and evaluate it at the same time. Watching yourself perform is what degrades the performance.
In creative work, the fear often speaks in a voice that sounds like your own standards: this isn't good enough. It presents itself as quality control. But genuine craft moves the work forward — it knows when something is done. The loop never lets it be done. That's the difference: real standards help you finish. The loop keeps you from finishing.
What you're experiencing is a state — a state of consciousness called fear — and states are not diseases. States move. When you're operating from fear, an audience looks like a jury, a draft looks like evidence against you, and a pause looks like a disaster.
Fear isn't a disorder. Fear creates disorder in your life.
The canceled talks, the drafts in the drawer, the years of not sharing — that's the disorder. But it's the output. Fear is the input.
Inner resistance is not wanting to feel nervous. Trying to stop the shake. Bracing before you walk up. Waiting until it feels safe to share. Any version of I can't do this until I'm not scared.
When you resist an emotion, it can't complete. It backs up as pressure — and you discharge it by rehearsing, revising, or avoiding. The loop is reinforced.
The work isn't to guarantee people will like what you do. It's to dissolve the resistance, so fear stops standing between you and what you have to say.
Public speaking anxiety and performance anxiety are commonly addressed with CBT, exposure-based practice, and acceptance-based approaches. (Skill development — speaking coaching, craft classes, lessons — is valuable in its own right and separate from the fear.) The framework you're about to meet is built on the same foundations, integrated with somatic work.
Here's the filter: if the loop runs on resistance, anything that doesn't dissolve resistance won't break it. More rehearsal can feed the need for certainty. Reassurance answers a question fear isn't actually asking. Shrinking your stage keeps you safe and costs you your voice.
What breaks it is the Triple-A Response® — a three-step process designed to put you into a state of inner non-resistance. With repetition, practice, and clarity, that state is what lets you truly confront the fear as an emotion inside yourself — the tight throat, the pounding chest — without pushing against it.
As you confront it, the fear begins to dissipate. As it dissipates, you shift into a different state of consciousness. And from there, you perceive everything differently.
Run it as a way to calm down before you go on, and it becomes another pre-show ritual. Run it correctly and the loop loses its fuel. That's what the assessment, the app, the book, and the program are built to walk you through.
Recovery is not about never feeling stage fright.
Many experienced performers still feel nerves beforehand.
Recovery is not about everyone loving your work.
Recovery is shifting your state of consciousness — out of fear, into trust.
In that state, you give the talk and you're actually talking to people. You play the song. You finish the piece and send it. You say the thing you came to say.
Fear tightens your throat and shortens your breath, which makes your voice less steady. And watching for the shake keeps your attention on it, which tends to make it worse.
They're the same loop in different settings. Public speaking anxiety covers presentations, meetings, speeches, and pitches. Stage fright usually refers to performing — music, theater, dance, comedy.
Often, yes. The blocked writer usually isn't out of ideas — they're stuck on the fear of what will happen when the ideas meet a reader. The inner critic that stops the first sentence is frequently the loop speaking.
Perfectionism driven by fear isn't aiming for excellent work — it's aiming for work that can't be criticized, which has no finish line. Genuine standards help you finish; the loop keeps you revising.
Exposure-based practice and CBT are well established. What matters is not just speaking more, but how you relate to the fear while you do — rehearsing and monitoring can keep the loop alive. The Restored Minds approach works on dissolving the resistance underneath it.
Your next step
The free assessment takes about five minutes and gives you a map of your own loop — the trigger, the behaviours, and the exact point where it keeps closing. Your answers are private.
Ready to see your loop?
Prefer to read first? From Stuck to Unstuck lays out the whole approach.
Restored Minds provides educational content and coaching — not a substitute for medical or mental-health treatment or emergency care. If you're in crisis, call or text 988 (Suicide & Crisis Lifeline), text HOME to 741741, or call 911.